On this week’s feedback replace, readers are debating a graffiti-covered home and sharing their views on different high tales.
Barefoot Architects has constructed a Corten steel-clad home behind an current brick wall in Bristol, England. It contains a uncommon built-in Edwardian publish field and graffiti.
The studio determined to include the previous brick wall into the design of the brand new home because it felt it “had immense character”.
“The graffiti provides it character”
Readers are divided. “The graffiti does give it character,” stated Velocity.
Apsco Radiales disagreed: “It is vulgar and it is vandalism. Why do not you let some ‘artists’ deface the partitions of your own home in case you suppose it provides it ‘character’?”
“Appears to be like like a rundown supply gate in a tragic laneway,” continued Marius.
“Amazed on the destructive feedback,” concluded JZ. “Extremely city, extremely contextual, and always in flux if the house owners proceed to permit folks to precise themselves. Graffiti is an artwork type people. So far as I am involved, these house owners are patrons.”
Is graffiti an artwork type? Be a part of the dialogue ›
“Dodged a cannonball” says commenter
Readers are torn over information that a part of the Indian Institute of Administration Ahmedabad – designed by architect Louis Kahn – is not going to be demolished as beforehand deliberate following worldwide outcry.
“Dodged a cannonball!” stated Puzzello. “I am unable to imagine how establishments so simply screw up relating to creating their wants and constructing new buildings.”
“Like most I used to be shocked to learn that demolition was even thought-about,” added Zea Newland. “However after listening to in regards to the questions of safety I’m wondering if the worldwide stress might need been unfair.”
Colin MacGillivray agreed: “Certainly a element of a constructing’s high quality is its structural sturdiness? The Kahn buildings are awful after a number of a long time – not earthquake resistant or weatherproof with deteriorating structural brick partitions.”
Ought to the Kahn-designed constructing be demolished? Be a part of the dialogue ›
“I fairly benefit from the story” says reader
Commenters aren’t satisfied by a pair of matching household residences, which have been constructed by Arhitektura on a slender website in Ljubljana. The homes are solely six metres large.
“Good narrative. I fairly benefit from the story,” stated Chaw Chee Yoong. “However the structure is meh.”
Sim continued: “Whereas the standard is seen and the ambitions admirable I discover the design fairly uneven and the rooms very slender.”
“This feels awkward and imbalanced,” added Zea Newland. “The design implies these homes have been tailor-made into an obscure slender plot with difficult environment, however it appears to be a relatively common suburban neighborhood that will have allowed for a extra typical design.”
What do you consider The Double Brick Home? Be a part of the dialogue ›
“Stop structure college now” says commenter
Readers are amazed {that a} home in suburban Adelaide, Australia, was designed by architect-in-training Reuben French-Kennedy. The coed designed the property as a retirement house for his mother and father.
“Stop structure college now!” pleaded Duckusucker. “You are already a really proficient designer and I doubt you’ve got far more to study. Definitely, constructing this house taught you greater than any remaining lessons would possibly. Bravo!”
Heywood Floyd agreed: “Good plan, nice house making, good observe via on large formal strikes getting reiterated on smaller scales all through for a pleasant coherent design. Wonderful siting and landscaping.”
As did Chris: “Actually a sharply executed home, I am fairly taken by it. Beautiful exterior type, inside plan and supplies.”
Are you impressed by Willunga Home? Be a part of the dialogue ›
Learn extra Dezeen feedback
Dezeen is the world’s most commented structure and design journal, receiving 1000’s of feedback every month from readers. Maintain updated on the newest discussions on our feedback web page.
Fundamental picture is by Anthony Coleman.