Simply earlier than Frank Berry left his job as head of Georgia’s Medicaid company this summer season, he mentioned the state “shall be on the lookout for the very best bang for the buck” in its upcoming contract with personal insurers to cowl the state’s most susceptible.
However whether or not the state — and Medicaid sufferers — are getting an optimum deal on Medicaid is up for debate.
Georgia pays three insurance coverage corporations — CareSource, Peach State Well being Plan and Amerigroup — over $4 billion in complete every year to run the federal-state medical insurance program for low-income residents and other people with disabilities. As a gaggle, the state’s insurers averaged $189 million per 12 months in mixed earnings in 2019 and 2020, based on insurer filings recorded by the Nationwide Affiliation of Insurance coverage Commissioners. But Georgia lacks a number of the monetary guardrails utilized by different states.
“Relative to different states, Georgia’s Medicaid market is a sexy enterprise proposition for managed-care corporations,” mentioned Andy Schneider, a professor at Georgetown College’s Heart for Youngsters and Households.
Georgia is amongst greater than 40 states which have turned to managed-care corporations to manage Medicaid prices. These contracts are usually among the many largest in these states, with billions of presidency {dollars} going to insurance coverage corporations. Insurers assume the monetary danger and administrative burden of offering providers to members in alternate for a set month-to-month payment paid for every member.
The well being plans, although, have at occasions drawn questions each on spending and high quality of care delivered to Medicaid members.
“The transition to managed care was supposed to avoid wasting states cash, however it’s not clear that it did,” mentioned Katherine Hempstead, a senior coverage adviser on the Robert Wooden Johnson Basis. (KHN receives funding assist from the muse.)
States can require Medicaid insurers to pay again cash in the event that they don’t hit a specified patient-spending threshold. That threshold is often 85% of the quantity paid to the insurance coverage corporations, with the remainder going to administration and revenue.
However Georgia doesn’t require its Medicaid insurers to hit a particular goal for spending on affected person care, a federal inspector basic report famous. Although Georgia is attempting to “claw again” $500 million paid to its Medicaid insurers, it might have misplaced out on recoupment {dollars}, the report indicated.
And state paperwork present that the Peach State firm, which now has the biggest Medicaid enrollment of the three insurers, failed to succeed in the 85% mark from 2018 to 2020.
Total, Georgia’s Medicaid “medical loss ratio,” which assesses how a lot was spent on sufferers’ claims and bills, was fifth from the underside nationwide final 12 months, behind solely Mississippi; Washington, D.C.; Wisconsin; and Arkansas, based on knowledge from the insurance coverage commissioners affiliation. Spending charges on affected person care within the state fell from 82.9% to 80.8% in 2020. (The NAIC makes use of a unique technique for calculating the ratio than the state and federal governments do.)
“Income for Georgia Medicaid HMOs are very wholesome,” mentioned Allan Baumgarten, an unbiased analyst and advisor.
When requested whether or not Georgia deliberate a spending requirement within the new contract, Fiona Roberts, spokesperson for the Division of Neighborhood Well being, which runs Medicaid, mentioned “quite a lot of concerns are being mentioned.” She famous that the state having a low medical loss ratio doesn’t essentially translate to “unreasonable revenue” for the insurers.
The insurers additionally earn a living off their administration providers companies. In 2020, the insurer Peach State paid a subsidiary of its mother or father firm, Centene Administration Firm, $114.7 million for administrative providers. The nonprofit CareSource paid its administration providers agency $86.5 million in 2020.
“Charges paid to subsidiary corporations symbolize one other supply of revenues for the mother or father corporations,” mentioned Baumgarten. “And it’s finished in a manner that doesn’t enable the state to carry the HMOs accountable.”
The state’s newest efficiency knowledge, which covers 2019, reveals the plans did as nicely or higher than the nationwide median on many measures, together with on entry to a major care supplier.
However low birthweight charges look like on the rise regardless of the state’s objective of bringing them down to eight.6% or much less. The businesses hovered at a median of about 9.8% in 2019, the newest obtainable knowledge.
“We proceed to listen to tales from households and well being care suppliers about kids in Medicaid managed care who’ve appreciable hassle getting the providers they want — whether or not it’s treatment to manage their bronchial asthma, getting related to behavioral well being care after a psychological well being disaster lands them within the emergency room, or any variety of well being challenges,” mentioned Melissa Haberlen DeWolf, who directs analysis and coverage on the Voices for Georgia’s Youngsters advocacy group.
In contrast with different states, Georgia has a stunningly low fee of referring poor kids to specialty providers beneath Medicaid, based on a lately launched Nationwide Well being Regulation Program report. DCH mentioned lately it’s investigating why the speed is so low.
And, at present, the state is reporting low covid vaccination charges for these 12 and older coated by the Medicaid managed-care corporations. A state posting reveals the charges for the three corporations are every under 10%, far decrease than Georgia’s general fee.
The businesses, when requested about profitability, high quality of care and administrative prices, directed a reporter to Jesse Weathington, government director of the Georgia High quality Healthcare Affiliation commerce group. He mentioned he couldn’t touch upon particular person corporations’ monetary efficiency.
“Our objective is to proceed to drive high quality enchancment, and profitable affected person outcomes, in essentially the most cost-efficient method for taxpayers who fund Georgia Medicaid,” Weathington mentioned.
Georgia is anticipated to open the high-stakes bidding course of on a brand new Medicaid contract subsequent 12 months. The bid course of usually is fierce and the outcomes usually contested.
It’s not clear, although, when Georgia’s new contract course of shall be accomplished because the timelines have hit snags in a number of different states. North Carolina rolled out its managed-care system July 1 after two years of delays. It should spend $6 billion yearly, the biggest contract within the state well being company’s historical past.
Final 12 months, Louisiana’s contract course of fell aside after insurers that misplaced out disputed the outcomes. And Centene and different corporations are protesting Pennsylvania’s determination to not award them contracts, delaying implementation.
St. Louis-based Centene has extra Medicaid managed-care enterprise nationally than another firm. Centene final 12 months acquired WellCare, a Medicaid insurer in Georgia, then closed down that operation in Could.
Centene has additionally confronted questions on overbilling. Ohio settled an $88 million pharmacy fraud lawsuit it filed in opposition to Centene months earlier than awarding it a contract, whereas Mississippi settled with it for almost $56 million. Now Georgia is anticipated to get a reimbursement beneath the $1 billion that Centene put aside to settle with different states affected by the pharmacy overbilling.
Client teams need the state to take stronger steps to advance the well being of those that depend on Medicaid and to make the offers with the insurers extra clear.
“Medicaid members are greatest served after they have prepared entry to suppliers, insurers are desirous to resolve their well being care wants, and policymakers train robust oversight to make sure members’ well being and well-being are prioritized over earnings,” mentioned Laura Colbert, government director of Georgians for a Wholesome Future, a client advocacy group.
A invoice that aimed to convey extra transparency and accountability to the state’s well being care plans was vetoed final 12 months by Republican Gov. Brian Kemp. The laws would have allowed a committee to look at data of well being care contractors and compel the state to answer questions on them. Kemp mentioned the invoice would have violated the separation of powers doctrine between the chief and legislative branches of presidency.
KHN (Kaiser Well being Information) is a nationwide newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about well being points. Along with Coverage Evaluation and Polling, KHN is likely one of the three main working applications at KFF (Kaiser Household Basis). KFF is an endowed nonprofit group offering info on well being points to the nation.
USE OUR CONTENT
This story could be republished without cost (particulars).