The U.S. and Russia open high-stake talks on the destiny of Ukraine on Monday, however prospects for a decision — or any settlement — are dim, diplomats say.
Moscow and Washington are worlds aside on whether or not Ukraine ought to be embraced by the West or forged its lot with Vladimir Putin’s Russia. And U.S. Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken has needed to wrestle to construct unity amongst America’s allies on methods to defend Kyiv from an more and more aggressive Russia.
“It’s very onerous to make precise progress” with Russia “in an environment of escalation and menace with a gun pointed to Ukraine’s head,” Blinken mentioned forward of the talks.
Russia, which invaded part of Ukraine practically eight years in the past, has amassed some 100,000 troops alongside the border in latest weeks and spewed a marketing campaign of invective, accusing Ukraine and the NATO alliance of posing a looming menace.
After a few phone conversations between Presidents Biden and Putin, and dozens of different lower-level consults, the 2 governments agreed to a gathering Monday in Geneva of the Strategic Stability Dialogue, a U.S.-Russia working group established final yr to give attention to arms management, adopted by conferences the remainder of the week involving NATO and different bigger multilateral organizations. The U.S. delegation is being led by Deputy Secretary of State Wendy Sherman.
Biden, Blinken and NATO officers have issued dire warnings to Russia if it have been to observe by means of with one other invasion of Ukraine. Most punishment would contain extra financial sanctions on Moscow, Putin and Russian oligarchs, the Western officers say. Quite a few sanctions already in place, nonetheless, have failed to change Putin’s conduct.
Most officers are ruling out navy motion past persevering with to arm Ukraine forces and, presumably, repositioning extra NATO troops on the japanese flank of NATO territory that features international locations reminiscent of Poland.
“A diplomatic resolution continues to be doable and preferable,” Blinken mentioned. “If Russia chooses it.”
E-newsletter
Get our Important Politics e-newsletter
The most recent information, evaluation and insights from our politics groups from Sacramento to D.C.
You could sometimes obtain promotional content material from the Los Angeles Occasions.
Ukraine has symbolism for each the U.S. and Russia that extends previous its real-life position. For Putin, it represents a part of the misplaced energy of the Soviet Union, which he yearns to reestablish. In Washington, Ukraine got here to symbolize the corruption of the Trump administration after then-President Trump tried to safe political favors from President Volodymyr Zelensky, actions that led to Trump’s first impeachment.
The broader concern, nonetheless, is how Russia and the remainder of U.S.-allied Europe will coexist. A lot of Europe — together with nations as soon as a part of the previous Soviet bloc — at the moment are a part of the North Atlantic Treaty Group with the US and Canada.
NATO growth into the a part of the world he considers Russia’s area infuriates Putin.
U.S. diplomats are additionally anxious about presenting a united entrance to Russia. Main powers reminiscent of Germany have rhetorically condemned Moscow’s belligerence however are extra depending on Russia for vitality and commerce than the U.S. is. They might be inclined to chorus from powerful actions to punish Putin.
The U.S. says it has dedicated $2.5 billion in “defensive” navy tools to Ukraine during the last seven years and would ramp that up if Russia continued its aggressive place.
“President Biden has instructed President Putin, ought to Russia additional invade Ukraine, we are going to present extra defensive materials to the Ukrainians above and past that which we already are within the strategy of offering,” a senior State Division official mentioned in a briefing of reporters performed on situation of anonymity.
William Taylor, a former U.S. ambassador to Ukraine who turned a star witness in Trump’s first impeachment hearings, is amongst a number of officers and consultants who advocate ramping up sanctions towards Moscow now moderately than ready for an invasion.
“In the event you wait till [Putin] strikes, you might be responding, not deterring,” he mentioned.
U.S. administration officers mentioned they may be capable of discover some widespread floor with Russia on broader arms management, missile deployments, navy workout routines or related points. However each the U.S. and Russia have bottom-line calls for that the opposite facet considers nonstarters.
Putin needs a pledge that NATO won’t increase additional. NATO Secretary-Basic Jens Stoltenberg reiterated Friday that international locations that need to be a part of the 30-nation alliance shall be welcome to use.
And for Washington, Russian de-escalation is crucial.
The upcoming talks could also be a begin, Taylor mentioned, “however nothing actually critical goes to occur so long as Russia is mounting troops” on the fringe of Ukraine.